ISSN 2071-8594

Russian academy of sciences

Editor-in-Chief

Gennady Osipov

A. V. Solovyev, V. E. Krivcov Expert Competency Modeling

Abstract.

The paper considers a methodological approach to modeling the competence of experts conducting the expertise of scientific projects carried out in organizations, as well as by grants from scientific foundations. The proposed approach has been pre-tested and will improve the efficiency of implementation and the quality of expertise in various areas of the modern digital economy.

Keywords:

multi-criteria choice, expert competence, trust, opinion, recommendation, reputation, interdisciplinary research.

PP. 32-39.

DOI 10.14357/20718594190304

References

1. Hong J.-C., Chang J.-O. Constructing an educational policy acceptance model to explore attitudes toward policy implementation: Using an industrial competency standards system in science and technology universities // Journal of Research in Education Sciences, 2018, №63 (2), pp. 251-284.
2. Zapatero Ayuso, J.A., Campos Izquierdo, A., González Rivera, M.D. The initial and continuing training of physical education teachers for application of competency model: A qualitative study // Revista Complutense de Educacion, 2018, №29(1), pp. 251-267.
3. Violato, C., Gao, H., O’Brien, M.C., Grier, D., Shen, E. How do physicians become medical experts? A test of three competing theories: distinct domains, independent influence and encapsulation models // Advances in Health Sciences Education, 2018, №23(2), pp. 249-263.
4. Malekan, H.S., Adamiak, K., Afsarmanesh, H. A systematic approach for business service consolidation in virtual organizations // Service Oriented Computing and Applications, 2018, №12(1), pp. 41-57.
5. Jøranli, I. Managing organisational knowledge through recruitment: searching and selecting embodied competencies // Journal of Knowledge Management, 2018, № 22(1), pp. 183-200.
6. Jazayeri, E., Liu, H., Dadi, G.B. Creating a safety training and competence model for construction craft professionals // Construction Research Congress 2018: Safety and Disaster Management - Selected Papers from the Construction Research Congress 2018, pp. 241-250.
7. Akifi Sh.S. Sravnitelniy analiz nacional’nih modeley professional’nih kompetenciy gosudarstvennih sluzhastshih [COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF NATIONAL MODELS OF PROFESSIONAL COMPETENCES OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEES] // Obrazovaniye i obstshestvo [Education and society]. 2017. T. 5-6. № 106-107. PP. 121-125.
8. Esaulova I.A. Razvitiye chelovecheskih resursov; evoluciya koncepciy i praktik [DEVELOPMENT OF HUMAN RESOURCES: EVOLUTION OF CONCEPTS AND PRACTICES] // Ekonomika truda [Labor Economics]. M.: "Kreativnaya ekonomika" [Creative economy], 2018. T. 5. № 1. PP. 13-28.
9. Veshneva I.V., Prokofyeva L.P., Bol’shakova A.A. Ocenka adekvatnosti modeley formirovaniya kompetenciy, postroennih na osnove metoda statusnih funkciy [EVALUATION OF ADEQUACY MODELS OF FORMATION OF COMPETENCES BUILT ON THE BASIS OF STATUS FUNCTIONS METHOD] // Informacionniye tehnologii v obrazovanii “ITO-SARATOV- 2017” materialy IX Vserossiyskoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferencii [INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES IN EDUCATION ITO-SARATOV-2017 Proceedings of the IXth All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference]. SPb.: Izdatel’skiy centr “Nauka” [Publishing Center "Science"], 2017. PP. 405-408.
10. Formirovaniye effektivnih upravlencheskih resheniy v usloviyah neopredelennosti: sovremenniy opit, perspektivy, innovacii [FORMATION OF EFFECTIVE MANAGERIAL DECISIONS IN THE UNCERTAINTY CONDITIONS: MODERN EXPERIENCE, PROSPECTS, INNOVATIONS] / Borisova L.V. and others. : monogr. Rostov-on-Don, 2018, 233 p. ISBN: 978-5-9500447-3-1.
11. Rytov A.I., Fiofanova O.A. Mezhdunarodniy analiz modeley, primenyaemih v praktike ocenki kompetenciy uchiteley [INTERNATIONAL ANALYSIS OF MODELS USED IN THE PRACTICE OF ASSESSMENT OF TEACHERS COMPETENCES] // Vissheye obrazovaniye segodnya [Higher education today]. M.: Logos ltd., 2017. № 3. PP. 49-55.
12. Faustov M.Yu. Issledovaniye modeley razvitiya klyuchevih kompetenciy v organizacii [RESEARCH OF MODELS OF DEVELOPMENT OF KEY COMPETENCES IN THE ORGANIZATION] // Nauka i iskusstvo upravleniya. Materialy IV Mezhdunarodnogo konkursa nauchnih rabot [Science and Art of Management Materials of the IV International Competition of Scientific Works]. Voronezh: "Ritm", 2017. PP. 280-283.
13. Gryaznov S.N., Dymkov A.V., Starostin A.S. O perspektivah uchastiya ekspertnogo soobtshestva v obespechenii deyatelnosti MCS Rossii [ON PERSPECTIVES OF PARTICIPATION OF THE EXPERT COMMUNITY IN ENSURING THE ACTIVITIES OF EMERCOM OF RUSSIA] // Strategiya grazhdanskoy zastshity: problem i issledovaniya [Civil Protection Strategy: Problems and Research]. M.: Centr strategicheskih issledovaniy grazhdanskoy zastshity Ministerstva Rossiyskoy Federacii po delam grazhdanskoy oborony, chrezvychaynim situaciyam i likvidacii posledstviy stihiynyh bedstviy [Center for Strategic Studies of Civil Protection of the Ministry of the Russian Federation for Civil Defense, Emergencies andDisaster Relief (public institution)], 2017. T. 7. № 2 (13). PP. 70-82.
14. Sovremenniye korporativniye strategii I tehnologii v Rossii [MODERN CORPORATE STRATEGIES AND TECHNOLOGIES IN RUSSIA] / Belyaeva I.Yu. and others. : monogr. M.: Finansoviy universitet pri pravitelstve Rossiyskoy Federacii [Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation], 2018, 458 p. ISBN: 975-5-7609-1341-8.
15. Bodrova M.I. Formirovaniye priverzhennosti sotrudnikov organozacii – bol’she vozmozhnostey dlya obeih storon? [FORMING THE ORGANIZATION OF THE EMPLOYEES OF THE ORGANIZATION IS MORE OPPORTUNITIES FOR BOTH PARTIES?] // Ekonomika I predprinimatel’stvo [Economy and Entrepreneurship]. M.: 2017. № 12-4 (89-4). PP. 915-926.
16. Arshinova V.V., Gubin O.I., Ionov A.A. Akadimicheskaya reputaciya universitetov v fokuse mezhdunarodnoy naukometrii [ACADEMIC REPUTATION OF UNIVERSITIES IN THE FOCUS OF INTERNATIONAL SCIENCE METHOD] // Alma mater (Vestnik vysshey shkoly [High School Bulletin]). M.: Innovacionniy nauchno-obrazovatelniy I izdatelskiy centr “Almavest” [Innovative scientific-educational and publishing center "Almavest"], 2018. № 5. PP. 5-10.
17. Dankin D.M. Simmetrichnoye doveriye – resurs strategii razvitiya [SYMMETRICAL TRUST - RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY] // Bezopasnost Evrazii [Security of Eurasia]. M.: Fond podderzhki issledovaniya problem “Bezopasnost Evrazii” [Foundation for the Study of Problems "Security of Eurasia"], 2017. № 1 (53). PP. 49-60.
18. Sinyaev V.V. Vektornaya model upravleniya delovoy reputaciey na rynke strahovih uslug [VECTOR MODEL OF BUSINESS REPUTATION MANAGEMENT IN THE MARKET OF INSURANCE SERVICES] // Obrazovaniye. Nauka. Nauchniye kadry. [Education. The science. Scientific personnel.] M.: Uniaty-Dana Ltd, 2018. № 1. PP. 105-108.
19. Skarzhinskaya E.M. Doveriye kak socialniy institute [TRUST AS A SOCIAL INSTITUTE] // Ekonomicheskaya nauka – hozyastvennoy praktike. Materialy XVIII Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferencii [Economic science - business practice Materials XVIII International Scientific and Practical Conference]. Kostroma: Kostromskoy gosudarstvenniy tehnologicheskiy universitet [Kostroma State Technological University], 2017. PP. 68-76.
20. Gubanova S.E. Doveriye kak osnova garmonizacii vzaimodeystviya biznes-struktur v usloviyah cifrovoy ekonomiki [TRUST AS A BASIS FOR HARMONIZATION OF THE INTERACTION OF BUSINESS STRUCTURES IN THE CONDITIONS OF THE DIGITAL ECONOMY] // Vestnik Volzhskogo universiteta im. V.N.Tatistsheva [Bulletin of the Volga University. V.N. Tatishcheva]. Tolyatti: 2018. T. 2. № 1. PP. 134-141.
21. Matyunenko Yu.A. Politicheskoye pozicionirovaniye gubernatorov:keys Rirovskoy oblasti [POLITICAL POSITIONING OF GOVERNORS: THE CASE OF THE KIROV REGION] // Biznes. Obstshestvo. Vlast’. [Business. Society. Power.] 2018. № 1 (27). PP. 163-178.
22. Sfenrianto, S., Wijaya, T., Wang, G. Assessing the buyer trust and satisfaction factors in the E-marketplace // Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research, 2018, №13(2), pp. 43-57.
23. Jafari Navimipour, N., Fouladi, P. Human resources ranking in a cloud-based knowledge sharing framework using the quality control criteria // Kybernetes, 2017, №46(5), pp. 876-892.
24. Ghiasi, H., Fathian Brojeny, M., Gholamian, M.R. A reputation system for e-marketplaces based on pairwise comparison // Knowledge and Information Systems, 2018, №56(3), pp. 613-636.
25. Bag, S., Azad, M.A., Hao, F. A privacy-aware decentralized and personalized reputation system // Computers and Security, 2018, №77, pp. 514-530.
26. Athanasiou, G., Anastassopoulos, G.C., Tiritidou, E., Lymberopoulos, D. A Trust Model for Ubiquitous Healthcare Environment on the Basis of Adaptable Fuzzy-Probabilistic Inference System // IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics, 2018, №22(4), pp. 1288-1298.
27. Dai, Y.N., Viken, G., Joo, E., Bente, G. Risk assessment in e-commerce: How sellers' photos, reputation scores, and the stake of a transaction influence buyers' purchase behavior and information processing // Computers in Human Behavior, 2018, №84, pp. 342-351.
28. Constantinov, C., Mocanu, M., Poteraş, C., Popa, B. Using a graph database for evaluating and enhancing a social reputation engine // Proceedings of the 2018 19th International Carpathian Control Conference, ICCC 2018, pp. 518-523.
29. Yilong, Z., Huifang, J., Shuoshuo, Z., Xiaorui, W., Yuan, R. A C2C E-commerce trust model based on reputation // Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology, 2018, №96 (11), pp. 3555-3566.
30. Sanchez-Paredes, A., Fernandez-Pena, F., Urrutia-Urrutia, P., Naranjo-Avalos, H. A Reputation-based Shared Transport System. A Case Study of E-collaboration in the City of Ambato // 2018 5th International Conference on eDemocracy and eGovernment, ICEDEG 2018, pp. 269-274.
31. Theoriya prinyatiya resheniy [Decision theory]. / Petrovsky A. B. M.: Akademy, 2009. — 400 p. — ISBN: 978-5- 7695-5093-5.
32. Petrovsky A. B., Lobanov V. N. Mnogokriterial`ny`j vy`bor v prostranstve priznakov bol`shoj razmernosti: mul`timetodnaya texnologiya PAKS-M [Multi-criteria selection in the space of signs of large dimension: PAKS-M multimethod technology] // Iskusstvenny`j intellekt i prinyatie reshenij [Artificial Intelligence and Decision Making] . – 2014. – № 3. – С.92-104.
33. Blei D. M., Ng A. Y., Jordan M. I. Latent Dirichlet allocation // Journal of Machine Learning Research, 2003, Vol.3, pp. 993–1022.
34. Ivanova A.A., Gladilin S.A., Zhukovskiy A.E., Pliskin E.L. Baza dannih administrativnogo ucheta nauchnih publikaciy [Database for the administrative accounting of scientific publications] // Trudy ISA RAN [Proceedings of ISA RAS]. — 2018. — Specvypusk [Special Issue], 2018. — PP. 83-89. — DOI: 10.14357/20790279180509.