ISSN 2071-8594

Russian academy of sciences

Editor-in-Chief

Gennady Osipov

G. I. Shepelev Comparing of Fuzzy Alternatives in Pairs of Different Configurations by Collective Risk Estimating Method

Abstract.

Analytical relationships were obtained for the chances of preference of the compared objects within pairs of fuzzy polyinterval alternatives of different localization as well as the associated risks. Collective risk estimating method is used in the work to compare the alternatives. The obtained results are of independent importance and also supplement the relationships established earlier for comparing fuzzy polyinterval alternatives with using the “mean-risk” method. This makes it possible to use a multimethod complex approach for comparing polyinterval objects that increases the validity of the comparison results.

Keywords:

pairwise comparison of fuzzy polyinterval alternatives, collective risk estimating method, analytical relationships for calculating chances of preference and risks.

PP. 47-54.

DOI 10.14357/20718594200405

References

1. Orlovsky S. Problemy prinyatiya resheny pri nechetkoi iskhodnoi informatsii. 1981. [Decision-making problems with fuzzy source information]. Moscow: Nauka. 208 p.
2. Chugunov N. Shepelev G., Sternin M. 2008. The generalized interval estimations in decision making under uncertainty // International Journal of Technology, Policy and Management. 8(3): 298–321.
3. Sternin M., Shepelev G. 2010. Generalized interval expert estimates in decision making // Doklady Mathematics. 81 (3): 485–486.
4. Dorohonceanu B., Marin B. 2002. A simple method for comparing fuzzy numbers. CAIP Center. Rutgers University. Piscataway. NJ 08854-8088.
5. Dushkin R.V. Metody polucheniya, predstavleniya i obrabotki znany s NE-faktorami. [Methods of obtaining, presenting and processing knowledge with NON-factors]. Moscow. 2011. 115 p. [Electronic resource].
6. Radaev A.V., Korobov A.V., Yatsalo B.I. 2018. F-Ranking: a computer system for ranking fuzzy numbers // Programmnye produkty i sistemy [Software Products and Systems]. (3): 605–613. DOI: 10.15827/0236-235X.123.605-613.
7. Fishburn P.C. 1977. Mean-risk analysis with risk associated with below-target returns // American Economic Review. 67(1): 116–126.
8. Podinovsky V. 2015. Chislovye mery riska kak kriterii vybora pri veroyatnostnoi neopredelennosti [Numerical risk measures as selection criteria for probabilistic uncertainty] // Iskusstvenny intellekt i prinyatie resheny [Artificial intelligence and decision-making] 2: 60–74.
9. Shepelev G. 2016. Decision-making in groups of interval alternatives // International journal «Information theories and applications». 23(4): 303–320.
10. Zhiyanov V.I., Shepelev G.I. 2018. Kompleksny metod sravneniya alternativ v usloviyakh riska [Comprehensive method for comparing interval alternatives under risk] // Vestnik TSEMI [Herald of CEMI]. 3 [Electronic resource]. URL: http://cemi.jes.su/s111111110000061-0-1 (circulation date:15.01.2019).
11. Shepelev G. 2019. Sravnenie poli intervalnykh alternative: metod “srednee – risk” [Comparing poly-interval alternatives: “mean-risk” method] // Iskusstvenny intellekt i prinyatie resheny [Artificial intelligence and decision-making]. 1: 16–26.
12. Shepelev G., Khairova N., Kochueva Z. Method “Mean – Risk” for comparing poly-interval objects in intelligent systems // Proceedings of the 3rd International Conferenceon Computational Linguistics and Intelligent Systems (COLINS-2019). Volume I: Main Conference, Kharkiv, Ukraine, April 18-19, 2019. CEUR Workshop Proceedings 2362, CEUR-WS.org 2019, p.12-21. URN:nbn:de:0074-2362-0 Electronic resource. http://ceur-ws.org, http://ceur-ws.org/Vol-2362/paper2.pdf.
13. Shepelev G. 2019. Sravnenie poli intervalnykh alternative: metod otsenki kollektivnogo riska [Comparing poly-interval alternatives: collective risk estimating method] // Iskusstvenny intellekt i prinyatie resheny [Artificial intelligence and decision-making] 3: 3-11.
14. Diligensky N., Dymova N., Sevastiyanov P. Nechetkoe modelirovanie i mnogokriterialnaya optimizatsiya proizvodstvennykh system v usloviyakh neopredelennosti: tekhnologiya, ekonomika, ekologiya [Fuzzy modeling and multi-criteria optimization of production systems under uncertainty: technology, economy, ecology]. Moscow: Engineering-1 Publs. 2004. 397 p.
15. Nedosekin A.O. Nechetko-mnozhestvenny analiz riska finanansovykh investitsy [Fuzzy-set analysis of risk for financial investments] S-Petersburg. Sezam. 2002. 181 p.